This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through my links I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. All opinions are my own.
Amazon Prime Day vs Black Friday: Which Has Better Deals
Two massive sale events, one question: where should you spend your money? The answer depends entirely on what you’re buying. Let’s break it down category by category.
Beauty and Skincare: Prime Day Actually Wins
Here’s the thing about beauty on Black Friday???it’s chaos. Everyone’s shopping for gifts, and the best sets sell out instantly. You’re competing with every other person trying to check off their gift list.
Prime Day is different. Comparable discounts, way less competition. The inventory is more reliable. And you’re not panic-buying for a holiday deadline.
Prime Day beauty winners:
First Aid Beauty???Cleansers hit their lowest prices during Prime Day. The Hydrating Cleanser is non-foaming, doesn’t strip your skin barrier. The Moisturizing Cream comes in huge tubs that last months. [Check Current Price on Amazon]
Neutrogena???Sunscreens and moisturizers discounted during Prime Day. Black Friday discounts are similar but sell out faster because everyone’s shopping at once. [Check Current Price on Amazon]
Good Molecules???Bundle deals that make already cheap products cheaper. Niacinamide for pores. Hyaluronic acid for hydration. The AHA/BHA peeling solution for exfoliation. [Check Current Price on Amazon]
Neutrogena???Hydro Boost line hits its best prices during Prime Day. [Check Current Price on Amazon]
Paula’s Choice???The BHA exfoliant drops to its lowest price during Prime Day. Black Friday stock is unpredictable???you might get the deal, you might get a “sold out” message. [Check Current Price on Amazon]
Hair Tools: It’s a Tie (But Prime Day Is Less Stressful)
Both events discount high-end styling tools at similar levels. The difference? Black Friday stock issues are legendary. You see a deal, you click, and it’s already gone.
Prime Day inventory is more reliable. You’ve got a better shot at actually getting the product you want.
Deals to watch at both events:
Conair Airwrap???Discounted during both Prime Day and Black Friday. Pick your timing based on when you need it. The tool styles and dries simultaneously using air instead of extreme heat. [Check Current Price on Amazon]
T3 Tools???Styling irons and brushes discounted at both events. The SinglePass technology maintains even heat. [Check Current Price on Amazon]
Moroccanoil???Sets discounted equally at both events, but Prime Day has better availability. Black Friday, you might miss out. [Check Current Price on Amazon]
Electronics: Black Friday Usually Wins
TVs, laptops, gaming systems???Black Friday has deeper discounts. Retailers clear inventory for the new year, and they’re fighting for your holiday shopping budget.
Prime Day electronics deals are solid but rarely Black Friday level. If you need a new laptop or TV and can wait until November, wait.
Gift Sets: Black Friday Wins (With Caveats)
Beauty gift sets peak during Black Friday. Brands release holiday exclusives that don’t exist during Prime Day. Limited edition palettes. Exclusive fragrance sets. Holiday packaging.
But: Popular sets sell out instantly. If you’re not clicking at midnight when the deals go live, good luck. You’ll get picked-over options or nothing at all.
Prime Day gift sets are more generic???everyday products in slightly better packaging. But at least they’re in stock.
Prime Day Pros
Less chaos than Black Friday
Better inventory availability
Early start on holiday shopping without the December stress
No crowds, no lines, no parking lot wars
Often identical discounts to Black Friday on beauty and hair tools
Black Friday Pros
Better electronics and appliance deals
Exclusive holiday gift sets
More retailer competition (not just Amazon???Target, Walmart, Best Buy all fighting for your money)
End-of-year clearance pricing on big-ticket items
My Strategy
For beauty, skincare, and hair tools? I shop Prime Day. Comparable discounts, way less competition. I’m not fighting crowds or clicking frantically at midnight.
For electronics and holiday gift sets? I wait for Black Friday. The discounts are deeper, and I’m willing to deal with the chaos for those categories.
But here’s the thing: buy what you need when it’s discounted. Don’t wait for Prime Day if you’re out of moisturizer now. Don’t wait for Black Friday if your hair dryer just died. The “best” deal is the one on something you’ll actually use, when you actually need it.
The Bottom Line
Prime Day wins for beauty and skincare. Black Friday wins for electronics and exclusive gift sets. Hair tools are a toss-up, but Prime Day is less stressful.
Both events are designed to make you spend more than you planned. Stick to your list. Check price history with CamelCamelCamel or Keepa. And if the “deal” is higher than it was three months ago? It’s not a deal.
Your wallet doesn’t care which event you shop???it cares that you’re buying things you actually need at prices that are actually lower.
